
Sarcasm aside, I’m not sure where I read about the study, but I seem to remember they said that turning the phones off and handing them to the teachers or placing them in a container before class were two options. In some schools, it might have been by choice that they released their technology lifeline, if I remember correctly.
Whether by choice or mandated, it’s been DISCOVERED that the kids seem to learn more without their phone connection. Focus is up. Creativity rises. Engagement increases.
It all sounds so simple, doesn’t it? Why didn’t this happen sooner? And, why doesn’t every school apply this principle (FYI, for the sake of humor I just used my phone to determine whether to use “principle” or “principal” in this sentence; I was 98 percent sure, but just wanted to be grammatically correct)?
When you don’t have the phone, it eliminates some (not all) distractions. That doesn’t mean students won’t look at someone they are attracted to. It doesn’t mean they won’t marvel at the snowstorm billowing outside and hoping classes will be cancelled so they can go home and head to the local hill for some sledding. It doesn’t mean students won’t look outside on a nice spring day and see the birds whizzing by, the trees budding and grass growing greener and want to running around playing tag or some other warm day inspired activity.
No, kids will be kids, whether they are 11- or 17-years-old. They will find ways to not pay attention. Sometimes even choose to disrupt the class because they can. Some will just plain be jerks.
Eliminating phones in the classroom is a big step in a positive direction. It also sets a tone: there is a right time and wrong time to be on the phone. “Right now you need to think on your own, work with your classmates, interact, listen to each other, and figure out a solution to the problem I just posted,” the teacher says.
Real life will have those mandated interactions in their future. Much is loaded, saved and available on our phones, but the individual must still figure out what to do with it. So many answers to so many of our questions. That is all well and good, and not about to go away any time soon.
So, what’s the challenge for educators? What’s the challenge in the classroom?
Quite frankly, it’s to learn all those other skills that bode well for a student’s future. They must learn how to think critically, how to discern truth from fiction, how to determine the facts of a situation and come up with workable options to solve problems. And do this by bouncing ideas off others, arguing, debating, listening, choosing.
One of the cell carriers currently advertises putting your phone away for one hour, one day, one week. I like it. It also sends a strong message to step away and get back into real life.
If more schools and other influencers begin to hold solid sway over our massive cell phone use, there is hope us human creatures will improve our relations with each other. Keep pushing.